Greek Loanwords in Sanskrit Astrology
Sanskrit horoscopic astrology uses a set of technical terms that are Greek words in Sanskrit dress. This is the least disputed evidence in a field where a good deal is disputed, and unlike the dating of any particular text it does not depend on an editor’s emendations.
The words
Horā, the hour and by extension the branch of astrology concerned with the horoscope, is ὥρα. Drekkāṇa, the third of a sign, is δεκανός, the decan. Dvādaśāṃśa, the twelfth-part, is δωδεκατημόριον. Kendra, the angle of a chart, is κέντρον. Jāmitra, the opposition, is διάμετρον. The word yavana itself, used of the source of the material, derives from the name of the Ionians 1.
What this establishes
Loanwords establish contact, and they establish direction for the specific vocabulary they cover: these particular technical terms travelled from Greek into Sanskrit rather than the reverse.
Correction
Commonly saidGreek technical loanwords in Sanskrit astrology show that Indian horoscopic astrology was imported wholesale from Greek, and date when it happened.
Loanwords do not establish that a whole system was imported. A tradition can borrow a vocabulary and build something its lenders would not recognise, and Sanskrit horoscopic astrology contains a great deal, the lunar mansions, the period-systems and the divisional charts among it, for which no Greek antecedent is claimed even by those who argue hardest for Greek influence.
Nor do loanwords date the contact. A word entering a language leaves no timestamp, and the attempt to date the encounter precisely from a single text is exactly what came apart under examination; see The Yavanajātaka and its Dating.
The traffic in the other direction
The borrowing was repeated, and ran in both directions. Sanskrit astronomical material reached Baghdad in the eighth century and entered the Arabic tradition, from which Latin Europe later drew; see The Zīj al-Sindhind. From the thirteenth century onward Sanskrit authors absorbed Perso-Arabic technique in turn, under the name tājika 2 pp. 79-132. Balabhadra’s Hāyanaratna of 1649 is that later synthesis in a critically edited text 3.
A tradition that borrowed a Greek vocabulary, exported its astronomy westward, and then re-imported a Persianate technical apparatus is not well described as either derivative or self-contained. Martin Gansten has said in print that the division between South Asian astrology and what is commonly called western astrology is a false dichotomy, since the second category counter-intuitively takes in Mesopotamia, Egypt, Sasanian Persia and the Arabic-speaking world 2 p. 79.
Gap in the evidence
This entry cites the loanwords as they are reported in the secondary literature and does not adjudicate individual etymologies. The direction of borrowing for these particular terms is not in dispute in that literature; the wider question of how much of the system travelled with them is, and this site does not settle it.
References
- David Pingree. Jyotiḥśāstra: Astral and Mathematical Literature. A History of Indian Literature, Vol. VI, Fasc. 4: Otto Harrassowitz, 1981, v + 149 pp.. ISBN 9783447021654 recordscholarly
The bibliographic map of the field: which Sanskrit astral texts exist, in what state, and what has been edited.
- Bill M. Mak. The Date and Nature of Sphujidhvaja's Yavanajātaka Reconsidered in the Light of Some Newly Discovered Materials. History of Science in South Asia 1, 2013, 1-20. doi:10.18732/H2RP4T recordpeer reviewed
Open access. Shows that Pingree's dating of the Yavanajātaka rests on readings the manuscripts do not carry, and that the celebrated "earliest Indian zero" was Pingree's own conjectural insertion.
- Kim Plofker. Mathematics in India: Princeton University Press, 2009. ISBN 9780691120676 recordpeer reviewed
The readable modern synthesis, more cautious than Pingree in tone and in several conclusions.
- David Pingree. Hellenophilia versus the History of Science. Isis 83, 1992, 554-563. doi:10.1086/356288 recordpeer reviewed
Pingree arguing against the assumption that Greek science is the measure of all other science. Required alongside any citation of Pingree on Greek influence, because the crude charge of Hellenocentrism does not survive it.